Johnson & Johnson Suffers Another Significant Loss in Talcum Powder Litigation
In a recent development in the ongoing legal battle surrounding talcum powder and its potential health risks, an Oregon jury has found Johnson & Johnson (J&J) liable for $260 million in damages to Kyung Lee, a 48-year-old woman who claimed she developed Mesothelioma, a rare and aggressive cancer linked to asbestos exposure, after using the company’s talc powder products for more than three decades.
5 Key Points
- The jury awarded Kyung Lee and her husband $60 million in compensatory damages and $200 million in punitive damages.
- Lee alleged that she inhaled asbestos-tainted talc from J&J’s products since infancy, as her mother used it on her as a baby, and she continued using it herself as a deodorant for over 30 years.
- Johnson & Johnson maintains that its talc products are safe, do not contain asbestos, and do not cause cancer, citing decades of scientific studies that support their safety.
- The company faces lawsuits from more than 61,000 plaintiffs over talc, with the majority being women with ovarian cancer and a small minority involving people with Mesothelioma.
- J&J is pursuing a proposed $6.48 billion settlement through a prepackaged bankruptcy to resolve most talc-related lawsuits, requiring the support of 75% of the remaining plaintiffs.
Johnson & Johnson to Appeal the Verdict
In response to the jury’s decision, Erik Haas, J&J’s worldwide vice president of litigation, stated that the verdict “is irreconcilable with the decades of independent scientific evaluations confirming talc is safe, does not contain asbestos, and does not cause cancer.” The company plans to appeal the verdict and is confident it will be reversed.
Plaintiff’s Long-Term Exposure to Talc Products
Kyung Lee’s exposure to J&J’s talc powder began in infancy when her mother used it on her as a baby. She continued using the product as a deodorant for over 30 years. During the trial, a lawyer for J&J argued that Lee’s illness was likely caused by exposure to asbestos used at a factory near where she grew up, rather than the company’s talc products.
Johnson & Johnson’s Efforts to Resolve Talc Lawsuits Through Bankruptcy
As the number of talc-related lawsuits continues to grow, J&J is currently pursuing a proposed $6.48 billion settlement through a prepackaged bankruptcy to resolve most of these cases. The company requires the support of 75% of the remaining plaintiffs to gain approval for the settlement, which would end the litigation, shut off future cases, and prevent people from opting out of the deal.
Courts have previously rejected two of the company’s efforts to resolve the talc cases through bankruptcy. However, J&J remains confident that support from plaintiffs will allow the latest attempt to succeed.
Plaintiffs Oppose Johnson & Johnson’s Settlement Proposal
Not all plaintiffs are in favor of J&J’s proposed settlement. On May 22, a group of plaintiffs filed a class action lawsuit aiming to stop the deal, calling it a “fraudulent” abuse of the bankruptcy system.
Mixed Outcomes in Previous Talc Trials
Trials involving talc cases have had varying outcomes, with some significant wins for plaintiffs. In 2021, a $2.1 billion judgment was awarded to 22 women with ovarian cancer. However, in April of this year, J&J won an ovarian cancer case but was hit with a $45 million verdict in a mesothelioma case.
The Ongoing Debate Surrounding Talcum Powder Safety
The Oregon verdict is the latest in a series of legal battles that have raised concerns about the safety of talcum powder products. While Johnson & Johnson maintains that its products are safe and do not contain asbestos, plaintiffs argue that the company has been aware of the potential risks associated with talc for decades.
The scientific community has also been divided on the issue, with some studies suggesting a link between talc use and certain cancers, while others have found no significant association. As more lawsuits are filed and additional research is conducted, the debate surrounding the safety of talcum powder is likely to continue.
The Impact on Johnson & Johnson and the Talc Industry
The Oregon verdict and the ongoing litigation have significantly impacted Johnson & Johnson and the talc industry as a whole. The company has faced increased scrutiny and reputational damage, with some consumers questioning the safety of its products.
In response to the growing concerns, some manufacturers have reformulated their talc products or shifted to alternative ingredients. The long-term effects of the talcum powder lawsuits on the industry remain to be seen. Still, the issue has raised important questions about product safety and corporate responsibility.
The Future of Talcum Powder Litigation and Consumer Safety
The $260 million verdict against Johnson & Johnson in the Oregon talcum powder lawsuit is a significant development in the ongoing legal battle surrounding the safety of talc products. As the company continues to face thousands of lawsuits and pursues a settlement through bankruptcy, the debate surrounding the potential health risks associated with talcum powder will likely persist.
The outcome of this case and others like it may have far-reaching implications for Johnson & Johnson, the talc industry, and consumers who have used these products for decades. As more information comes to light and additional research is conducted, companies must prioritize consumer safety and transparency to maintain public trust and prevent further harm.
On this page:
